Dark Sector Or Alone in the Dark?

^^which game should i getDark Sector Or Alone in the Dark?
It's a question I'd like the answer to aswell.Dark Sector Or Alone in the Dark?
Alone in The Dark, Ignore all this negativity BS about the game it's only people sayin the game is bad and then other ppl just copying them
I obviously don't know if Alone in the Dark is good or not, but Dark Sector was very fun.For me DS was the perfect rent: fun gameplay, about 8 hour campaign, great to have for few days.
i would say alone in the dark, i played dark sector and i found my self more pissed off about the feel of the game then having fun, but im worried about the replay value for Alone in the Dark......but i say it would be better anyway =]
im asking because i know that alone in the Dark is already out in other parts of the world, so anyone who has played both which game would you say i should get, i wanted to know ahead of time because i know that gamestop has an offer that if you pre-order alone in the dark you save 10.00$ on it when you pick it up and i am going in today or tomorrow to pre-order BF:BC andmabey AITD
Alone in the dark looks like a really good game, but i also think Dark Sector was very under-rated, my friend let me have a go on it and i thought it was really good.
my friend just got the game and im watching him play it on webcam...he says that it got good physics and has some cool moments but its got terrible controls and is buggy and broken at times...it looks cool but im not sure the 'coolness' will last long...